Fruit & Nut Butters

Showing all 30 results

• 

  Amish Peanut Butter Spread

  $9.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Apple Butter

  $12.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Apple Butter

  $8.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Apple Butter – N/S

  $8.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Apple Butter 9oz

  $6.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Apple Butter N/S 9oz

  $6.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Apple Pecan Butter

  $8.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Apple Walnut Butter

  $8.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Authentic Amish Peanut Butter Spread

  $8.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Blackberry Butter

  $8.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Carmel Pecan Apple Butter

  $8.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Cherry Butter

  $8.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Chocolate Amish Peanut Butter Spread

  $10.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Chocolate Amish Peanut Butter Spread 16oz

  $15.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Homemade Peanut Butter Marshmallow Spread

  $9.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Peach Butter

  $8.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Peach Butter 8oz

  $7.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Peanut Butter Marshmallow Spread 1.5oz

  $4.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Peanut Butter Marshmallow Squeeze Spread

  $8.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Pear Butter

  $8.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Pear Butter 9oz

  $6.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Pumpkin Butter

  $8.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Pumpkin Butter – N/S

  $8.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Pumpkin Butter 9oz

  $6.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Pumpkin Pistachio Butter

  $8.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Scherger’s Amish Peanut Butter Spread 18oz

  $15.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Sweet Potato Butter

  $8.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Sweet Potato Butter – N/S

  $8.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Sweet Potato Pecan Butter

  $8.99
  Add to Cart
• 

  Zimmermans Natural Peanut Butter No Sugar Added

  $9.99
  Add to Cart